Saturday, September 1, 2012

Reflective Paper on "The Allegory of the Cave" by Plato (Ethics of Leadership)


Nobody wants to be a fool. The only way to escape foolishness is to pursue wisdom, and so each of us, in one way or another whether we realize it or not, seeks to find wisdom. However, we do not all have the same concept of wisdom and so we chase after it in different ways peculiar to our view. Plato believes in the existence of absolute truth and calls it the “essential Form of Goodness” (231). He hopes that exposing us to this Form of Goodness, this pure truth, will straighten out our view of life and give us a new way to live. For Plato, wisdom is an accurate understanding, one based on our own personal experience, of the “essential Form of Goodness” that produces in us a revitalized life built on our change of perspective.

Plato acknowledges that his understanding of absolute truth is limited, but he still believes in its existence. He states, “Heaven knows whether it is true; but this, at any rate, is how it appears to me” (231). Here we can see a basic philosophy that truth can exist regardless of our knowledge of it. Just because he thinks his reasoning to be correct does not mean that it is. This is why he advocates the seeking of wisdom; a complete comprehension of the “essential Form of Goodness” is always beyond our grasp yet we should absorb every bit of it that we can so our lives will be more and more closely oriented to that truth. Maturity is the ability to view truth “as it is in itself in its own domain” (230). Plato sees this truth objectively; he knows that he cannot influence or change it. His opinion of the truth may be in error but this does not affect the truth itself.

Truth is so hard to see and act upon wisely because we must change to fit its mold yet we resist change. Like the prisoners who “would recognize as reality nothing but the shadows of those artificial objects” (229), we often reject chances to understand truth more fully. This is simply because the bounds of our ability to reason are too small at the time of the opportunity. If we were to gaze suddenly upon the fullness of truth then we would be so blinded as to see nothing, disbelieve its veracity, and then turn back to our old ways. In the end, we would be far worse off because we would become callous to the truth. Having falsely experienced it once, we would immediately reject any further experiences. Plato believes that we must become “enlightened or unenlightened” in “degrees” (227) if we are ever to attain to a full understanding of the truth. We must grow into it.

We cannot hoard our newfound wisdom if we are to be truly mature. Once we have found out a broader view of the truth, we must not keep it to ourselves, but, instead, we should use that new perspective on life to lead others wisely. Plato argues that true leaders are those who could leave and be better off, yet they choose to stay and lead for the benefit of those below them. (235) “So whom else can you compel to undertake the guardianship of the commonwealth, if not those who, besides understanding best the principles of government, enjoy a nobler life than the politician’s and look for rewards of a different kind?” If leaders are in love with their positions of leadership, then they are not fit to lead because then they will begin to contend among themselves for the office rather than using the office for the benefit of the populace.

Plato understands wisdom to be the “virtue of some diviner faculty, which never loses its power, though its use for good or harm depends on the direction towards which it is turned” (233). Our ability to reason can be used to harm or for good depending on where it faces. Wisdom is the compelling of our reason lead us into right living based on our understanding of the “essential Form of Goodness.” It is not the “essential Form of Goodness” which morphs, but our subjective knowledge of it. We must be exposed to this truth incrementally rather than suddenly, lest we reject it because of our limitations. Once we have found the truth, then we must use that newfound wisdom for the benefit of our fellow citizens. We humble ourselves to return to those void of wisdom and patiently, slowly expose them to the truth so that they can live with new meaning as well.

No comments:

Post a Comment